Dear Vince . . .
Some Modest Proposals To
Cure Major League Invisibility
By Bob Andelman
Originally published in The Maddux Report
October, 1999
There cannot be a more dedicated baseball fan than St. Petersburg sports and business book author Bob Andelman. He chronicled the city’s stumbling attempts to land a major league team before the Devil Rays took the field. He cheers every hit, cringes at every blip, hopes with every pitch and swing of a Devil Rays bat. But while the team was concluding a respectable second season in the Bigs, he noticed a certain ineptitude off the field. Like all good citizens concerned about a civic issue, he took up his pen.
Dear Mr. Naimoli,
I love baseball and I have spent the last two years living and dying
each day according to the Devil Rays latest exploits. My wife and I have
two season tickets and will be adding a third for my daughter next season.
I can’t believe how lucky we are to live ten minutes away from Tropicana
Field and Major League Baseball 81 days a year.
The reason I’m writing to you now is that I’m troubled by the ineptitude
of the team’s marketing and how drooping attendance in the 1999 season reflected
upon unfairly upon our community. Of the millions reportedly invested in
marketing the team this year, very little was well spent.
Furthermore, with the Lightning (NHL) and Storm (Arena Football) getting
new ownership, and the championship hopes of the sold-out Buccaneers, the
level of competition for sports dollars will be a real brawl in the coming
months. No one wants to see “financially troubled” become the two words that
precede news reports of the Rays.
Over the course of the Rays’ second year, I developed a list of ideas that
I thought might help raise the team’s profile for 2000 and broaden its fan
base. Bear in mind, of course, that I don’t have the credentials of St. Petersburg
Mayor David Fischer’s blue-ribbon panel, the geniuses who think the solution
lies in better community relations. I’m simplistic enough to think turning
around attendance can be found in lessons from Advertising 101.
Here is what I came up with:
* TROPICANA FIELD. Have you heard the old adage, “A business with no sign
is a sign with no business”? Why, four years after you were awarded a franchise
and named it the Tampa Bay Devil Rays, is there still no giant team logo
painted on the Trop and facing Interstate 275, just a block away? The cock-eyed,
green “Tropicana Field” neon letters are embarrassingly small against the
enormous pale front of the stadium. You certainly juiced that sponsor.
And while we’re at it, Flower Power Park (formerly Al Lang Field), where
your Florida State League St. Petersburg Devil Rays play, has better signage
than the Trop. If Flower Power Park needs a flashing red LED sign promoting
upcoming minor league games and giveaways in a part of the city with very
little auto or foot traffic, doesn’t it make sense to put a similar sign
in sight of the thousands of drivers who pass the stadium daily on I-275?
* BILLBOARDS. Speaking of highways, I logged a lot of hours this summer driving
back and forth between Tampa and Altamonte Springs on I-4. What struck me
as strange was that the new WNBA franchise, the Orlando Miracle, put a billboard
near downtown Tampa soliciting fans but there wasn’t a single billboard on
I-4 in Orlando (or anywhere else on I-4) selling the Devil Rays to residents
and tourists 90 miles away. Yet virtually every other attraction at one end
of the I-4 corridor advertises its wares at the other end.
Orlando made a credible presentation to baseball back in 1991 when the Florida
Marlins were created. But I have yet to meet anyone there who has been to
a Rays game. Have you tried putting Rays schedules in the thousands of hotel
brochure racks over there? Surely the Rays aren’t writing off that entire
market already.
Maybe the issue is billboards in general. Because while the Buccaneers, Lightning
and Orlando Magic have a virtually year-round presence selling season tickets
on billboards around the Bay area, the Devil Rays are virtually invisible.
And thanks to the hideous “Off The Wall” campaign, which made no sense (wouldn’t
“OVER the Wall” have promised more?) and featured such a small Rays logo
as to be indecipherable, the handful of billboards the team used were pointless.
Next season, use more billboards and keep it simple. Big Rays logo, use logos
of opposing teams and change it every week (a la the Florida Lottery) to
reflect the latest games and developments. And putting something like “Good
Seats Still Available” in big type wouldn’t hurt, either.
* PLAYERS. More than halfway through the ’99 season, the team actually did
promotions based on Jose Canseco’s home runs and Wade Boggs’ quest for 3,000
hits. What took so long?
In the off-season, please consider getting your veterans contracts settled
early so the 2000 season ticket campaign can focus on them. And don’t underestimate
the appeal of younger players such as Bubba Trammell (no other player has
an entire section of fans screaming their name) and pitching phenom Ryan
Rupe (“Rupe There It Is”).
* TV. As I understand it, the Rays produce their own TV and radio broadcasts.
If that is the case, why is there no consistency in the graphics from telecasts
on Sportschannel Florida to Ch. 10 to Ch. 32? It’s frustrating.
* FANS BEYOND TAMPA BAY. Maybe an appeal needs to be made to the business
side of newspapers such as the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, Bradenton Herald,
Lakeland Ledger and Orlando Sentinel to draw their readers into the ballpark.
While the St. Petersburg Times apparently brought the signage rights within
the Trop, maybe papers that it doesn’t compete with could somehow be brought
into visibility.
The team brought down the price of upper-deck tickets in the second half
of the ’99 season. Why not honor the citizens of various Central Florida
communities once a week next year by offering half-price tickets to them
by showing ID? You could collect names and addresses of buyers and follow
up with direct mail solicitations to bring them back again and again.
* EXISTING SEASON TICKET HOLDERS. The time has come to welcome ALL season
ticket holders — with an ID issued by the team — to the exclusive Club
level. For one thing, it would be a nice perk, but more important to your
wallet, that area is currently D-E-A-D. For all its potential — the new
restaurant, full bar, carving stations, concierge — it doesn’t draw flies.
* FREE YEAR-ROUND ADVERTISING. How about sending an “I Love the Devil Rays/1-800-FAN-RAYS”
bumper sticker or window cling to every known ticket buyer in your data base?
* INSIDE THE TROP. Take a look around Raymond James Stadium where the Bucs
play. Everywhere you look is the team logo, big bold and imposing. This is
something the Rays could stand to imitate within the Trop.
* KIDS. Here is an area in which I think the team is already doing a wonderful
job. Raymond is a fabulous mascot, albeit underused. Kids dig him and can’t
get enough of him. Letting the youngsters run the bases at the Trop after
Sunday afternoon games was a great idea, judging by the hundreds of kids
and parents who lined up week after week to try it. Giveaway items have been
top-quality. (The Wade Boggs doll was hysterical.) The Reading Tree is a
great idea that needs to be located to a more central location. The Kids’
Corner, offering smaller food portions at discount prices makes baseball
as a family experience far more palatable for the budget-minded.
* THREATS. Don’t say another word about moving the team, even under your
breath. You have too many opportunities to market baseball across Central
Florida for fans to ever have to hear another word of that nonsense. Besides,
nobody knows better than Tampa Bay fans how hard it is to convince baseball
to relocate a franchise. If it were easy, we’d all be rooting for the Tampa
Bay Mariners. Or the Tampa Bay Giants. Or the . . .
Best wishes,
Bob Andelman